For a Modest Human Exceptionalism: Simone de Beauvoir and the "New Materialisms"
Abstract
The “new materialisms” offer an important critique of “human exceptionalism,” challenging
deeply held conceptions of “man” as a “sovereign subject.” However, they tend
to overstate their claims by ignoring those qualities of freedom that still remain distinctive
to human life. This article turns to Beauvoir to make a case for a more “modest”
human exceptionalism: while she also grounds the human inextricably in the material,
Beauvoir offers fuller resources than do new materialisms for examining human
freedom and human responsibility to resist its oppression.