In Ben A. Minteer (ed.), Environmental Ethics. Temple University Press. pp. 87-100 (2009)
The convergence hypothesis asserts that, if one takes the full range of human values—present and future—into account, one will choose a set of policies that can also be accepted by an advocate of a consistent and reasonable nonanthropocentrism. Brian Steverson has attacked this hypothesis from a surprising direction. He attributes to deep ecologists the position that nonhuman nature has intrinsic value, interprets this position to mean that no species could ever be allowed to go extinct, and proceeds to show that my commitment to contextualism prohibits me from advocating the protection of species universally. In response, I show, by reference to recent scientific findings, how difficult it is to defend species preservation in all situations. In particular, I argue that Steverson’s appeal to a possible world in which we have nearly complete biological knowledge misses the point of the convergence hypothesis. It is an empirical hypothesis, with significant indirect, and some direct, evidence to support it. Although it is a falsifiable hypothesis about realworld policies, it cannot be falsified by a contrary-to-fact case
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Convergence and Contextualism: Some Clarifications and a Reply to Steverson.Bryan G. Norton - 1997 - Environmental Ethics 19 (1):87-100.
Contextualist Approaches to Epistemology: Problems and Prospects.Elke Brendel & Christoph Jäger - 2004 - Erkenntnis 61 (2-3):143 - 172.
Convergence and Divergence: The Convergence Hypothesis Twenty Years Later.Bryan G. Norton - 2009 - In Ben A. Minteer (ed.), Nature in Common?: Environmental Ethics and the Contested Foundations of Environmental Policy. Temple University Press.
Convergence, Noninstrumental Value and the Semantics of 'Love': Reply to Norton.Katie McShane - 2008 - Environmental Values 17 (1):15-21.
Hold the Context Fixed, Vagueness Still Remains.Jonas Åkerman & Patrick Greenough - 2010 - In Sebastiano Moruzzi & Richard Dietz (eds.), Cuts and Clouds. Oxford University Press. pp. 275--88.
Contextualism and Norton's Convergence Hypothesis.Brian K. Steverson - 2009 - In Ben A. Minteer (ed.), Environmental Ethics. Temple University Press. pp. 135-150.
Contextualism and Norton's Convergence Hypothesis.Brian K. Steverson - 1995 - Environmental Ethics 17 (2):135-150.
Added to index2010-07-20
Total downloads6 ( #553,284 of 2,158,205 )
Recent downloads (6 months)2 ( #195,105 of 2,158,205 )
How can I increase my downloads?