AbstractThis brief essay commenting on Paul Butler's article, "Race Based Jury Nullification: Black Power in the Criminal Justice System," prepared for the Criminal Law Conversations project, argues that Professor Butler's proposal of race-based jury nullification to address the African-American community's perception of racial injustice in the administration of the criminal laws, particularly the drug laws, confuses cause and effect. The most important cause of African-American dissatisfaction with the criminal justice system is its inability to keep inner-city communities safe. A regime of race-based jury nullification, in turn, would aggravate rather than ameliorate this serious problem.
Similar books and articles
The Defence of Belief in Consent: Guidelines and Jury Instructions for Application of Criminal Code Section 265(4).Lucinda Vandervort - 2005 - Criminal Law Quarterly 50 (4):441-452.
Re-justifying the fair cross section requirement: Equal representation and enfranchisement in the american criminal jury.Richard M. Re - unknown
Equalizing unequal justice : Responding to William J. stuntz, unequal justice, 121 harv. L. rev. 1669 (2008).Dennis J. Baker - unknown
Preferences for juries over judges across racial and ethnic groups.Mary R. Rose, Christopher G. Ellison & Shari Seidman Diamond - manuscript
Grassroots Marketing in a Global Era: More Lessons from BiDil.Britt M. Rusert & Charmaine D. M. Royal - 2011 - Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 39 (1):79-90.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads