2009-03-19
|
The 'Explanatory Gap'
|
Derek AllanAustralian National University
|
The notion of an explanatory 'gap' suggests that something about consciousness has already been explained satisfactorily. What is that, I wonder?
The notion of a gap is also potentially misleading since it implies that the method being used is OK but that it can't quite get us to the target - or can't just yet. But the fact that something cannot be explained by a certain method may also mean that the method is completely inappropriate to the task. Then we are not talking about a 'gap' but a kind of abyss - or, to change the metaphor, a philosophical dead end.
The term 'gap', in other words, betrays a certain philosophical complacency, does it not?
|