In Defense of Political Equality: On Bai Tongdong’s Against Political Equality

Journal of Confucian Philosophy and Culture 37:59-90 (2022)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Bai Tongdong’s Against Political Equality argues for Confucian meritocracy over a pure democracy of equals. His arguments draw on a multiple modernities comparison between the Spring and Autumn Warring States period in China and early modernity in the West, and rest on a Mencian conception of human nature according to which humans are equal in moral potential but not in moral actuality. I argue that there is a crucial disanalogy between this Chinese early modernity and Western early modernity: the role of capitalism. In a similarly comparativist and modernist spirit, drawing on B. R. Ambedkar and M. K. Gandhi, I argue that this disanalogy challenges both Bai’s critique of democracy and his positive account. Bai’s failure to take into account the role of capitalism in Western modernity raises a challenge to the explanatory power of his Mencian conception of human nature with regard to the failings of contemporary democracies, namely that capitalism fosters the relevant features of our moral psychology that cause those failings. Further, without that grounding assumption, Bai’s arguments against democracy cut equally against his Confucian meritocracy. The disanalogy also creates challenges for his positive proposal. Bai, I argue, provides an ideal theory of Confucian meritocracy at the same time as he provides a non-ideal theory of democracy. But, taking into account the non-ideal cultural and moral psychological features of capitalism, Bai’s Confucian meritocracy is likely to fall into an unjust and oligarchic hierarchy.

Links

PhilArchive

External links

  • This entry has no external links. Add one.
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

When Equality Matters.John Thrasher - 2018 - In David Boonin, Katrina L. Sifferd, Tyler K. Fagan, Valerie Gray Hardcastle, Michael Huemer, Daniel Wodak, Derk Pereboom, Stephen J. Morse, Sarah Tyson, Mark Zelcer, Garrett VanPelt, Devin Casey, Philip E. Devine, David K. Chan, Maarten Boudry, Christopher Freiman, Hrishikesh Joshi, Shelley Wilcox, Jason Brennan, Eric Wiland, Ryan Muldoon, Mark Alfano, Philip Robichaud, Kevin Timpe, David Livingstone Smith, Francis J. Beckwith, Dan Hooley, Russell Blackford, John Corvino, Corey McCall, Dan Demetriou, Ajume Wingo, Michael Shermer, Ole Martin Moen, Aksel Braanen Sterri, Teresa Blankmeyer Burke, Jeppe von Platz, John Thrasher, Mary Hawkesworth, William MacAskill, Daniel Halliday, Janine O’Flynn, Yoaav Isaacs, Jason Iuliano, Claire Pickard, Arvin M. Gouw, Tina Rulli, Justin Caouette, Allen Habib, Brian D. Earp, Andrew Vierra, Subrena E. Smith, Danielle M. Wenner, Lisa Diependaele, Sigrid Sterckx, G. Owen Schaefer, Markus K. Labude, Harisan Unais Nasir, Udo Schuklenk, Benjamin Zolf & Woolwine (eds.), The Palgrave Handbook of Philosophy and Public Policy. Springer Verlag. pp. 409-419.
Democracy and equality.Steven Wall - 2007 - Philosophical Quarterly 57 (228):416–438.
Which conception of political equality do deliberative mini-publics promote?Dominique Leydet - 2016 - European Journal of Political Theory 18 (3):147488511666560.
Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case.Tongdong Bai - 2019 - Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Bai Tongdong, Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case.Adrian Kreutz - 2021 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 18 (2):179-182.
Democracy is Where We Make It.Todd May - 2009 - Symposium 13 (1):3-21.
Democracy is Where We Make It.Todd May - 2009 - Symposium: Canadian Journal of Continental Philosophy/Revue canadienne de philosophie continentale 13 (1):3-21.
Reassessing Egalitarianism.Jeremy Moss - 2014 - Palgrave McMillan.
Equality.David Johnston (ed.) - 2000 - Hackett Publishing Company.
Ideals of Equality.Andrew Mason (ed.) - 1998 - Wiley-Blackwell.

Analytics

Added to PP
2023-05-22

Downloads
249 (#82,394)

6 months
145 (#24,640)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Yarran Hominh
Bard College

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references