Law, Culture, and Humanities:1-30 (2014)
Authors |
|
Abstract |
It is often said that human rights are the rights that people possess simply in virtue of being human – that is, in virtue of their intrinsic, dignity-defining common humanity. Yet, on closer inspection the human rights landscape doesn’t look so even. Once we bring perpetrators of human rights abuse and their victims into the picture, attributions of humanity to persons become unstable. In this essay, I trace the ways in which rights discourse ascribes variable humanity to certain categories of people. I set the stage for my discussion of the human in relation to human rights by examining John Locke’s account of the justification for punishment. For Locke, in committing a crime one abrogates one’s humanity and forfeits one’s rights. Likewise, I argue, human rights discourse takes a scalar view of humanity. I consider victims of genocide who are dehumanized as helpless and passive, victims of state persecution who are super-humanized as righteously agentic, and perpetrators of genocide who are dehumanized as out-of-control beasts. In each case I use relevant testimony to argue that the scalar view of humanity is factually incorrect and morally deplorable. For genocide victims, I discuss testimony that Selma Leydesdorff gathered from women who survived the Srebrenica massacre. For a victim of persecution, I discuss Liao Yiwu’s memoire of his detention and imprisonment in China because of his artwork protesting the Tiananmen Square massacre. For perpetrators of genocide, I discuss testimony Jean Hatzfeld gathered from Hutu men who systematically murdered Tutsis in the Rwandan genocide. Finally, I apply my critique of dehumanized and super-humanized victims and dehumanized perpetrators to the problem of transnational trafficking in persons and argue that the view I advocate necessitates reforming immigration policy with respect to persons trafficked into forced labor
|
Keywords | victims perpetrators, testimony human rights stories human nature, John Locke |
Categories | (categorize this paper) |
Options |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Download options
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
Mapping Dehumanization Studies (Preface and Introduction of Routledge Handbook of Dehumanization).Maria Kronfeldner - 2021 - In Routledge Handbook of Dehumanization. London, Vereinigtes Königreich:
The Human, Human Rights, and DNA Identity Tests.Noa Vaisman - 2018 - Science, Technology, and Human Values 43 (1):3-20.
Similar books and articles
Paradoxical Bedfellows: Nihilism and Human Rights. [REVIEW]Andrew Fagan - 2005 - Human Rights Review 6 (3):80-101.
A Human Rights Approach to Human Trafficking for Organ Removal.Debra Budiani-Saberi & Seán Columb - 2013 - Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 16 (4):897-914.
The Human Rights of Others: Sovereignty, Legitimacy, and "Just Causes" for the "War on Terror".Margaret Denike - 2008 - Hypatia 23 (2):pp. 95-121.
Dehumanising the Dehumanisers: Reversal in Human Rights Discourse.Robert Fine - 2010 - Journal of Global Ethics 6 (2):179-190.
Human Rights Reasoning and Medical Law: A Sceptical Essay.Jesse Wall - 2015 - Bioethics 29 (3):162-170.
Human Rights Without Foundations.Joseph Raz - 2010 - In J. Tasioulas & S. Besson (eds.), The Philosphy of International Law. Oxford University Press.
Defensive Enforcement: Human Rights in Indonesia. [REVIEW]Irene Istiningsih Hadiprayitno - 2010 - Human Rights Review 11 (3):373-399.
Narrative Structures, Narratives of Abuse, and Human Rights.Diana Tietjens Meyers - 2009 - In Lisa Tessman (ed.), Feminist Ethics and Social and Political Philosophy: Theorizing the Non- Ideal. Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Are Human Rights Essentially Triggers for Intervention?John Tasioulas - 2009 - Philosophy Compass 4 (6):938-950.
Crimes Against Humanity and the Limits of International Criminal Law.Massimo Renzo - 2012 - Law and Philosophy 31 (4):443-476.
Human Rights Enjoyment in Theory and Activism.Brooke Ackerly - 2011 - Human Rights Review 12 (2):221-239.
The Challenge of Human Rights: Origin, Development and Significance.John Mahoney - 2006 - Blackwell.
Analytics
Added to PP index
2014-05-19
Total views
534 ( #16,716 of 2,519,267 )
Recent downloads (6 months)
41 ( #20,989 of 2,519,267 )
2014-05-19
Total views
534 ( #16,716 of 2,519,267 )
Recent downloads (6 months)
41 ( #20,989 of 2,519,267 )
How can I increase my downloads?
Downloads