Beyond “Second Animals”: Making Sense of Plant Ethics [Book Review]
Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 27 (1):1-25 (2014)
Abstract |
Concern for what we do to plants is pivotal for the field of environmental ethics but has scarcely been voiced. This paper examines how plant ethics first emerged from the development of plant science and yet also hit theoretical barriers in that domain. It elaborates on a case study prompted by a legal article on “the dignity of creatures” in the Swiss Constitution. Interestingly, the issue of plant dignity was interpreted as a personification or rather an “animalization of plants.” This sense of irony makes sense when one realizes that on scientific grounds the plant is a “second animal,” i.e., it differs from the animal in degree of life or some ethically-relevant criterion but not in nature. From the point of view of ethics however, plants should be defended for what they are by nature and not by comparison to external references: the ethical standing of plants cannot be indexed to animals. It is thus reckoned that to circumvent this odd fetishism, the plant ethics can only be adequately addressed by changing the theory of plant science. Common sense tells us this: plants and animals belong to radically different fields of perception and experience, a difference that is commonly captured by the notion of kingdom. In this paper we remind the ethical conversation that plants are actually incommensurable with animals because they are unsplit beings (having neither inside nor outside), i.e., they live as “non-topos” in an undivided, unlimited, non-centered state of being. It is concluded that the unique ontology of plants can only be addressed through a major change from object-thinking to process-thinking and a move from ego-centric to “peri-ego” ethics
|
Keywords | Animal Biocentrism Epistemic standing Plant Post-ego Topos |
Categories | (categorize this paper) |
ISBN(s) | |
DOI | 10.1007/s10806-013-9439-x |
Options |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Download options
References found in this work BETA
View all 28 references / Add more references
Citations of this work BETA
Plants as Machines: History, Philosophy and Practical Consequences of an Idea.Sophie Gerber & Quentin Hiernaux - 2022 - Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 35 (1):1-24.
Integrität als Konzept der Naturethik. Eine Diskussion am Beispiel pflanzlichen Lebens.Angelika Kallhoff - 2020 - Zeitschrift Für Praktische Philosophie 7 (2):171-190.
Similar books and articles
A Unifying New Model of Cytokinesis for the Dividing Plant and Animal Cells.Pankaj Dhonukshe, Jozef Šamaj, František Balušak & Jiri Friml - 2007 - Bioessays 29 (4):371-381.
The History of the Plant Embryo. Terminology and Visualization From Ancient Until Modern Times.Hans Werner Ingensiep - 2004 - History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 26 (3/4):309 - 331.
Plant as Object Within Herbal Landscape: Different Kinds of Perception. [REVIEW]Renata Sõukand & Raivo Kalle - 2010 - Biosemiotics 3 (3):299-313.
Plant-Soul: The Elusive Meanings of Vegetative Life.Michael Marder - 2011 - Environmental Philosophy 8 (1):83-99.
Learning Plants: Semiosis Between the Parts and the Whole. [REVIEW]Ramsey Affifi - 2013 - Biosemiotics 6 (3):547-559.
Comparative Analysis of the Risk-Handling Procedures for Gene Technology Applications in Medical and Plant Science.Anna Lydia Svalastog, Petter Gustafsson & Stefan Jansson - 2006 - Science and Engineering Ethics 12 (3):465-479.
Hierarchical Ordering in Plant Morphology.Robert W. Korn - 1994 - Acta Biotheoretica 42 (4):227-244.
Plant Cell Wall Signaling in the Interaction with Plant-Parasitic Nematodes.Krzysztof Wieczorek & Georg J. Seifert - 2012 - In Witzany & Baluska (eds.), Biocommunication of Plants. Springer. pp. 139--155.
Plant Hormones and Metabolites as Universal Vocabulary in Plant Defense Signaling.Dirk Balmer & Brigitte Mauch-Mani - 2012 - In Witzany & Baluska (eds.), Biocommunication of Plants. Springer. pp. 37--50.
The Least Harm Principle May Require That Humans Consume a Diet Containing Large Herbivores, Not a Vegan Diet.Steven L. Davis - 2003 - Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 16 (4):387-394.
Growing Weed, Producing Knowledge An Epistemic History of Arabidopsis Thaliana.Sabina Leonelli - 2007 - History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 29 (2):193 - 223.
Analytics
Added to PP index
2013-11-22
Total views
34 ( #332,739 of 2,498,795 )
Recent downloads (6 months)
1 ( #421,542 of 2,498,795 )
2013-11-22
Total views
34 ( #332,739 of 2,498,795 )
Recent downloads (6 months)
1 ( #421,542 of 2,498,795 )
How can I increase my downloads?
Downloads