Social Philosophy Today 29:21-31 (2013)
AbstractIn this article I assert that deliberative democratic theory, as articulated by Jürgen Habermas and Seyla Benhabib, explicitly fails to live up the demands of its discourse-ethical foundation when we examine undocumented immigrants who live in any given nation. In the case of undocumented immigrants, there is a gap which exists between a moral imperative to include those affected by a norm in discourse, and legal structures which actualize this imperative. I offer the following account in an effort to show how one might bridge this gap. First, virtual representation of undocumented interests by the citizens of a bounded community is not sufficient to correct the dilemma of deliberative democracy. Second, I will claim that the rhetorical power of personal testimony from marginalized individuals is required for a responsible judgment in discourse. Finally I will discuss practical forums for this participation which can potentially solve the dilemma of deliberative democracy. Through direct confrontation with those who are unjustly marginalized, we can cross the divide that exists between a moral imperative to respect the undocumented and a legally-recognized right to participate in discourse.
Similar books and articles
Crossing the Divide: Marginalized Populations and the Dilemma of Deliberative Democracy.Kyle Thomsen - 2013 - Social Philosophy Today 29:21-31.
Liberal, Republican and Deliberative Democracy.Henning Ottmann - 2006 - Synthesis Philosophica 21 (2):315-325.
Possible application of deliberative democracy in parliament.Branislav Dolný - 2011 - Human Affairs 21 (4):422-436.
Can deliberative democracy be Partisan?Russell Muirhead - 2010 - Critical Review: A Journal of Politics and Society 22 (2-3):129-157.
A democracia de liberativa: a institucionalização discursiva da unidade da razão na multiplicidade das suas vozes.Karl Heinz Efken - 2011 - Veritas – Revista de Filosofia da Pucrs 56 (3):125-144.
Communicative Democracy: A Version of Deliberative Democracy.Adela Cortina - 2010 - Archiv für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie 96 (2):133-150.
Deliberative democracy and the internet: Could online deliberative democracy replace classical democracy.Zeljko Mancic - 2012 - Filozofija I Društvo 23 (2):168-186.
Between deliberative and participatory democracy: A contribution on Habermas.Denise Vitale - 2006 - Philosophy and Social Criticism 32 (6):739-766.
The rhetoric of deliberation: Some problems in Kantian theories of deliberative democracy.John O'Neill - 2002 - Res Publica 8 (3):249-268.
The substantive dimension of deliberative practical rationality.Pablo Gilabert - 2005 - Philosophy and Social Criticism 31 (2):185-210.
Language, Power, and Persuasion: Toward a Critique of Deliberative Democracy.Margaret Kohn - 2000 - Constellations 7 (3):408-429.
War, manipulation of consent, and deliberative democracy.William S. Lewis - 2008 - Journal of Speculative Philosophy 22 (4):pp. 266-277.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads