In Defense of Tigers and Wolves: A Critique of McMahan, Nussbaum, and Johannsen on the Elimination of Predators from the Wild

Ethics and the Environment 27 (1):17-38 (2022)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Abstract:McMahan, Nussbaum, and Johannsen have recently suggested that humans should seek to eliminate predators from the wild or avoid reintroducing them if this can be done without great harm to an ecosystem. This is because predators cause a great deal of pain to those sentient animals which are their prey. This paper will first challenge the pragmatic aspects of such a position on the global level, arguing that it would be extremely difficult if not impossible to remove predators from the environment without doing great ecological harm. Because removal of predators might be considered more feasible on the micro scale this paper will go on to challenge the axiological foundations of such a view. In particular defenders of the removal of predators from the environment tend to base their position on the preferencing of the disvalue of pain over the value of life. Yet if life itself has value it can be a good even with those beings that cause pain to others. Moreover, there is a value to diverse forms of life that must also be acknowledged. An ecosystem with diverse habits and life forms exercising different ways of being has great value even if again this comes at the cost of suffering and pain to some of the creatures in it. Once these things are understood it is clear that predators should not be eliminated from the wild and indeed should be reintroduced into ecosystems where they once flourished.

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 93,774

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Animals, predators, the right to life, and the duty to save lives.Aaron Simmons - 2009 - Ethics and the Environment 14 (1):pp. 15-27.
Painlessly Killing Predators.Ben Bramble - 2020 - Journal of Applied Philosophy 38 (2):217-225.
An Environmentalist’s Lament on Predation.Ty Raterman - 2008 - Environmental Ethics 30 (4):417-434.
From Lion to Tiger: The Changing Buddhist Images of Apex Predators in Trans-Asian Contexts.Xing Zhang & Huaiyu Chen - 2019 - In Rotem Kowner, Guy Bar-Oz, Michal Biran, Meir Shahar & Gideon Shelach-Lavi (eds.), Animals and Human Society in Asia: Historical, Cultural and Ethical Perspectives. Springer Verlag. pp. 331-353.

Analytics

Added to PP
2022-06-30

Downloads
29 (#135,560)

6 months
7 (#1,397,300)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Alan Vincelette
Marquette University (PhD)

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references