Pivotal cultural values of nature cannot be integrated into the ecosystem services framework
Abstract
In a recent issue of PNAS, Daniel et al. (1) attempted to advance the integration of cultural values and cultural ecosystem services (ES) into the ES framework. Although I agree with the authors that cultural values are of eminent importance, I see two flaws in their argument.
The range of cultural values correlating to ecological structures and functions is much more limited than they claim. Many cultural values attaching to the natural/cultivated environment cannot be addressed in this way. An area’s appropriateness for recreational activities like fishing or walking can be assessed in this way, but not its value with respect to feelings of belonging, …