How to read an ethics paper
Journal of Medical Ethics 44 (12):810-813 (2018)
Abstract
In recent decades, evidence-based medicine has become one of the foundations of clinical practice, making it necessary that healthcare practitioners develop keen critical appraisal skills for scientific papers. Worksheets to guide clinicians through this critical appraisal are often used in journal clubs, a key part of continuing medical education. A similar need is arising for health professionals to develop skills in the critical appraisal of medical ethics papers. Medicine is increasingly ethically complex, and there is a growing medical ethics literature that modern practitioners need to be able to use in their practice. In addition, clinical ethics services are commonplace in healthcare institutions, and the lion’s share of the work done by these services is done by clinicians in addition to their usual roles. Education to support this work is important. In this paper, we present a worksheet designed to help busy healthcare practitioners critically appraise ethics papers relevant to clinical practice. In the first section, we explain what is different about ethics papers. We then describe how to work through the steps in our critical appraisal worksheet: identifying the point at issue; scrutinising definitions; dissecting the arguments presented; considering counterarguments; and finally deciding on relevance. Working through this reflective worksheet will help healthcare practitioners to use the ethics literature effectively in clinical practice. We also intend it to be a shared evaluative tool that can form the basis of professional discussion such as at ethics journal clubs. Practising these critical reasoning skills will also increase practitioners’ capacity to think through difficult ethical decisions in daily clinical practice.Author's Profile
DOI
10.1136/medethics-2018-104997
My notes
Similar books and articles
Reading or scanning? A study of newspaper and net paper reading.Kenneth Holmqvist, Jana Holsanova, Maria Barthelson & Daniel Lundqvist - 2003 - In J. R. In Hyönä & H. Deubel (eds.), The mind's eye: cognitive and applied aspects of eye movement research. pp. 657 - 670.
Judith Butler and an Ethics of Humanization.Hülya Şimga - 2014 - Dialogue and Universalism 24 (3):166-173.
Professional Economic Ethics: Why Heterodox Economists Should Care.George DeMartino - 2013 - Economic Thought 2 (1).
The Ethics of Social Reform a Paper Read at a Meeting of the Fellowship of the New Life, London.M. Adams - 1887 - W. Reeves.
The Best Means of Raising Standards of Purity a Paper Read at the Carlisle Church Congress, Thursday, October 2nd, 1884.J. Griffith - 1884 - Bemrose.
Negotiating the Familiar and the Strange in Aztec Ethics.Kay A. Read - 1987 - Journal of Religious Ethics 15 (1):2 - 13.
The philosophy of Donald T. Campbell: A short review and critical appraisal. [REVIEW]Franz M. Wuketits - 2001 - Biology and Philosophy 16 (2):171-188.
Can We Inhabit the Moral Universe of Dante's Divine Comedy?Brian Horne - 2003 - Studies in Christian Ethics 16 (1):61-71.
Analytics
Added to PP
2018-10-04
Downloads
21 (#543,227)
6 months
1 (#450,425)
2018-10-04
Downloads
21 (#543,227)
6 months
1 (#450,425)
Historical graph of downloads
Author's Profile
Citations of this work
Ethical climate in contemporary paediatric intensive care.Katie M. Moynihan, Lisa Taylor, Liz Crowe, Mary-Claire Balnaves, Helen Irving, Al Ozonoff, Robert D. Truog & Melanie Jansen - 2021 - Journal of Medical Ethics 47 (12):14-14.
Developing new ways to listen: the value of narrative approaches in empirical (bio)ethics.Carlo Leget, Megan Milota & Bernadette Roest - 2021 - BMC Medical Ethics 22 (1):1-13.
References found in this work
Ethics consultation in united states hospitals: A national survey.Ellen Fox, Sarah Myers & Robert A. Pearlman - 2007 - American Journal of Bioethics 7 (2):13 – 25.
Health care ethics consultation: An update on core competencies and emerging standards from the American Society for Bioethics and Humanities' Core Competencies Update Task Force.Anita J. Tarzian & Asbh Core Competencies Update Task Force 1 - 2013 - American Journal of Bioethics 13 (2):3-13.
Development of clinical ethics services in the UK: a national survey.Anne Marie Slowther, Leah McClimans & Charlotte Price - 2012 - Journal of Medical Ethics 38 (4):210-214.
Project Examining Effectiveness in Clinical Ethics (PEECE): phase 1--descriptive analysis of nine clinical ethics services.M. D. Godkin - 2005 - Journal of Medical Ethics 31 (9):505-512.