Bioethics 31 (7):534-542 (2017)
AbstractEugene Mills has recently argued that human organisms cannot begin to exist at fertilization because the evidence suggests that egg cells persist through fertilization and simply turn into zygotes. He offers two main arguments for this conclusion: that ‘fertilized egg’ commits no conceptual fallacy, and that on the face of it, it looks as though egg cells survive fertilization when the process is watched through a microscope. We refute these arguments and offer several reasons of our own to think that egg cells do not survive fertilization, appealing to various forms of essentialism regarding persons, fission cases, and a detailed discussion of the biological facts relevant to fertilization and genetics. We conclude that it is plausible, therefore, that human organisms begin to exist at fertilization – or, at the very least, that there are grounds for thinking that they existed as zygotes which do not apply to the prior egg cells. While this does not entail that human persons begin to exist at this point, it nevertheless has considerable significance for this latter question.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
References found in this work
No references found.
Citations of this work
Even If the Fetus is Not a Person, Abortion is Immoral: The Impairment Argument.Perry Hendricks - 2019 - Bioethics 33 (2):245-253.
The Reality of Conscientious Objection: Response to Shahvisi.Toni C. Saad & David M. Rassam - 2019 - Clinical Ethics 14 (1):9-17.
Similar books and articles
The Origination of a Human Being: A Reply to Oderberg.Ingmar Persson - 2009 - Journal of Applied Philosophy 26 (4):371-378.
When Did I Begin?: Conception of the Human Individual in History, Philosophy, and Science.Norman M. Ford - 1988 - Cambridge University Press.
Sixteen Days? A Reply to B. Smith and B. Brogaard on the Beginning of Human Individuals.Gregor Damschen, Alfonso Gómez-Lobo & Dieter Schönecker - 2006 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 31 (2):165 – 175.
Human Persons, Human Organisms: Why Psychology is Not Relevant to Personal Identity.Eric Todd Olson - 1993 - Dissertation, Syracuse University
Embryo Experimentation and Sorites Paradoxes.Snjezana Prijic-Samarzija - 2004 - Etica E Politica 6 (2):1-19.
Totipotency, Twinning, and Ensoulment at Fertilization.Rose Koch-Hershenov - 2006 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 31 (2):139 – 164.
Fission and Confusion.David Hershenov & Rose Koch-Hershenov - 2006 - Christian Bioethics 12 (3):237-254.
Ethical Reflections on the Status of the Preimplantation Embryo Leading to the German Embryo Protection Act.Prof Dr H. W. Michelmann & B. Hinney - 1995 - Science and Engineering Ethics 1 (2):145-150.
'Show Me Your Original Face Before You Were Born': The Convergence of Public Fetuses and Sacred DNA.Scott F. Gilbert & Rebecca Howes-Mischel - 2004 - History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 26 (3/4):377 - 479.
Report of the Committee of Inquiry Into Human Fertilisation and Embryology.Mary Great Britain & Warnock - 1984
Aquinas's Account of Human Embryogenesis and Recent Interpretations.Jason Eberl - 2005 - Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 30 (4):379 – 394.
Emergency Contraceptives and the Beginning of Human Animals.Eze Paez - 2016 - Bioethics 30 (6):433-439.
Ethical Reflections on the Status of the Preimplantation Embryo Leading to the German Embryo Protection Act.H. W. Michelmann & B. Hinney - 1995 - Science and Engineering Ethics 1 (2):145-150.