Abstract

Theodore Drange wrote a response to my critique of his argument against the ’fine-tuning’ argument. In it, he defends the fundamental points in his original essay, and again states that the fine-tuning argument fails to support the existence of God. My reply is a refinement and defense of my original critique of Drange. Further, I argue that Drange’s dependence upon the notion that the universe and its laws are just brute facts that have no further explanation leads to insurmountable problems and, thus, cannot rescue him from my critique