Abstract

Jenefer Robinson specifies one very practical implication of her theory that literature offers an emotional education: "There is virtually nothing in [Ethan Frome and Silas Marner] for the average fifteen-year-old American (regardless of gender or ethnic background) to relate to his or her own experience" so that the reading of these two novels by fifteen-year-olds ends with "the dreadful result... that many kids are permanently alienated from two of the greatest novelists in the English language."1 According to Robinson, the average fifteen-year-old should not read Ethan Frome and Silas Marner because he has nothing in his experience through with which these novels emotionally engage him. This claim suggests..