Hobbes Studies 24 (1):91-111 (2011)
Very few—if any—will doubt Hobbes's aversion to the state of nature and sympathy for civil society. On the other hand, it is not quite news that it would be inaccurate to claim that Hobbes rejected the state of nature entirely. Indeed, he embraced or at the very least tolerated the state of nature at the international level in order to escape from the individual state of nature. Hobbes's recommended exchange of an individual state of nature for an international one does seem to have a smack of contradiction, arguably first noted by Rousseau. There is yet another charge of contradiction lurking around Hobbes's account of the state of nature. Hobbes's political thought would still reflect an ambivalent attitude towards a third instantiation of the state of nature, i.e. civil war. This is one of the main reasons why the political allegiance of Thomas Hobbes has been an issue ever since the publication of De Cive at the very least. This paper deals with Hobbes's differential treatment of the original and the international states of nature and discusses the source of Hobbes's somewhat ambivalent attitude towards civil war. It is here argued that Hobbes can fairly hold his ground vis-à-vis Rousseau's criticism, in spite of the normative resemblance between the international state of nature and the initial state of nature, and that Hobbes ambivalent attitude of attraction and repulsion towards civil war is actually due not so much to opportunism on his part as to the normative autonomy he has granted to the state of nature
|Keywords||WAR NEGATIVE ASSOCIATION STATE OF NATURE CIVIL WAR|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
State of Nature or Eden?: Thomas Hobbes and His Contemporaries on the Natural Condition of Human Beings.Helen Thornton - 2005 - University of Rochester Press.
Why Hobbes' State of Nature is Best Modeled by an Assurance Game.Michael Moehler - 2009 - Utilitas 21 (3):297-326.
Hobbes and Game Theory Revisited: Zero-Sum Games in the State of Nature.Daniel Eggers - 2011 - Southern Journal of Philosophy 49 (3):193-226.
Reason and Reciprocity in Hobbes's Political Philosophy: On Sharon Lloyd's: Morality in the Philosophy of Thomas Hobbes. Martinich - 2010 - Hobbes Studies 23 (2):158-169.
Political Theory and Practical Action: A Reconsideration of Hobbes's State of Nature.Richard Ashcraft - 1988 - Hobbes Studies 1 (1):63-88.
Hobbes's Conception of the State of Nature From L640 to L651.François Tricaud - 1988 - In G. A. J. Rogers & Alan Ryan (eds.), Perspectives on Thomas Hobbes. Oxford University Press. pp. 107--123.
Hobbes: Moral and Political Philosophy.Garrath Williams - 2003 - Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Philosophers of Peace: Hobbes and Kant on International Order.Sharon Anderson-Gold - 2012 - Hobbes Studies 25 (1):6-20.
James Dundas on the Hobbesian State of Nature.Alexander Broadie - 2013 - Journal of Scottish Philosophy 11 (1):1-13.
The Appropriation of Abandonment: Giorgio Agamben on the State of Nature and the Political. [REVIEW]Sergei Prozorov - 2009 - Continental Philosophy Review 42 (3):327-353.
Resisting the Scaffold: Self-Preservation and Limits of Obligation in Hobbes's Leviathan.Patricia Sheridan - 2011 - Hobbes Studies 24 (2):137-157.
Added to index2011-06-19
Total downloads76 ( #68,033 of 2,158,205 )
Recent downloads (6 months)6 ( #53,473 of 2,158,205 )
How can I increase my downloads?