Graduate studies at Western
Philosophical Perspectives 15 (s15):189-209 (2001)
|Abstract||It is easy to become battle-weary in metaphysics. In the face of seemingly unresolvable disputes and unanswerable questions, it is tempting to cast aside one’s sword, proclaiming: “there is no fact of the matter who is right!” Sometimes that is the right thing to do. As a case study, consider the search for the criterion of personal identity over time. I say there is no fact of the matter whether the correct criterion is bodily or psychological continuity.1 There exist two candidate meanings for talk of persisting persons, one corresponding to each criterion, and there is simply no fact of the matter which candidate we mean. An argument schema for this sort of “no fact of the matter” thesis will be constructed. An instance of the schema will be defended in the case of personal identity. But scrutiny of this instance will reveal limits of the schema. Questions not settled by conceptual analysis—in particular, some very difficult questions of fundamental ontology—have answers. So do certain questions that can be settled by conceptual analysis, namely those that would be answered definitively by ideal philosophical inquiry. Whether there is a fact of the matter is not easily ascertained merely by looking to see whether disputes seem unresolvable or questions unanswerable: sometimes the truth is out there, however hard (or even impossible) it may be to discover|
|Keywords||Conceptual Analysis Continuity Criteria Existence Metaphysics Persistence Personal Identity|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Amelie Oksenberg Rorty (ed.) (1976). The Identities of Persons. University of California Press.
Trenton Merricks (1999). Endurance, Psychological Continuity, and the Importance of Personal Identity. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 59 (4):983-997.
Steven Rieber (1998). The Concept of Personal Identity. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 58 (3):581-594.
R. G. Swinburne (1973). Personal Identity. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 74:231 - 247.
Theodore Sider (2000). Recent Work on Identity Over Time. Philosophical Books 41 (2):81–89.
Matti Eklund (2002). Personal Identity and Conceptual Incoherence. Noûs 36 (3):465-485.
J. M. Shorter (1962). More About Bodily Continuity and Personal Identity. Analysis 22 (March):79-85.
Eric Olson (2006). Is There a Bodily Criterion of Personal Identity? In Fraser MacBride (ed.), Identity and Modality. Oxford University Press.
Michael C. Rea & David Silver (2000). Personal Identity and Psychological Continuity. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 61 (1):185-194.
Trenton Merricks (2000). Perdurance and Psychological Continuity. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 61 (1):195-199.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads104 ( #7,263 of 739,303 )
Recent downloads (6 months)7 ( #13,419 of 739,303 )
How can I increase my downloads?