Frege on demonstratives

Philosophical Review 86 (4):474-497 (1977)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Demonstratives seem to have posed a severe difficulty for Frege’s philosophy of language, to which his doctrine of incommunicable senses was a reaction. In “The Thought,” Frege briefly discusses sentences containing such demonstratives as “today,” “here,” and “yesterday,” and then turns to certain questions that he says are raised by the occurrence of “I” in sentences (T, 24-26). He is led to say that, when one thinks about oneself, one grasps thoughts that others cannot grasp, that cannot be communicated. However, nothing could be more out of the spirit of Frege’s account of sense and thought than an incommunicable, private thought. In the first part of the paper, I explain the problem demonstratives pose for Frege, and explore three ways he might have dealt with it. I argue that none of these ways provides Frege with a solution to his problem consistent with his philosophy of language. The first two are plausible as solutions, but contradict his identification of the sense expressed by a sentence with a thought. The third preserves the identification, but is implausible. In the second part, I suggest that Frege was led to his doctrine of incommunicable senses as a result of some appreciation of the difficulties his account of demonstratives faces, for these come quickly to the surface when we think about “I.” I argue that incommunicable senses won’t help. I end by trying to identify the central problem with Frege’s approach, and sketching an alternative.

Similar books and articles

Frege: Two theses, two senses.Carlo Penco - 2003 - History and Philosophy of Logic 24 (2):87-109.
Sense, Reference and Ontology in Early Analytic Philosophy.Max Langan Rosenkrantz - 2000 - Dissertation, The University of Texas at Austin
Frege on Dichtung and Elucidation.Gisela Bengtsson - 2018 - In Gisela Bengtsson, Simo Säätelä & Alois Pichler (eds.), New Essays on Frege: Between Science and Literature. Cham, Switzerland: Springer. pp. 101-119.
Toward a New Theory of Fregean Sense.Jungshin Suh Rhee - 1992 - Dissertation, University of Illinois at Chicago
The Bonds of Sense: An Essay in the History of Analytic Philosophy.Michael Beaney - 1990 - Dissertation, University of Oxford (United Kingdom)


Added to PP

1,012 (#14,608)

6 months
153 (#28,228)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

John Perry
University of California, Riverside

Citations of this work

Materialism and qualia: The explanatory gap.Joseph Levine - 1983 - Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 64 (October):354-61.
The components of content.David J. Chalmers - 2002 - In David John Chalmers (ed.), Philosophy of Mind: Classical and Contemporary Readings. New York: Oxford University Press USA.
On sense and intension.David J. Chalmers - 2002 - Philosophical Perspectives 16:135-82.
Advertisement for a Semantics for Psychology.Ned Block - 1986 - Midwest Studies in Philosophy 10 (1):615-678.
Philosophy of Mind: Classical and Contemporary Readings.David John Chalmers (ed.) - 2002 - New York: Oxford University Press USA.

View all 374 citations / Add more citations

References found in this work

The thought: A logical inquiry.Gottlob Frege - 1956 - Mind 65 (259):289-311.

Add more references