History and Philosophy of Logic 24 (2):111-129 (2003)
This paper discusses the fallacies of combination and division as they are presented by Aristotle in chapter 4 of his Sophistici Elenchi. Aristotle's examples are concise, their discussion is unclear, and it is difficult to distinguish the cases of combination from those of division. I analyse the Aristotelian examples and the interpretations offered so far. I show that these interpretations suffer from a major defect: they fail to identify a common characteristic whereby the Aristotelian examples can be classified as instances of combination or division. In my reconstruction of the examples, I repair this deficiency: I give a single pattern of explanation for the fallacy of combination and another (similar) pattern for the fallacy of division. Thus, it is possible to free Aristotle from the following charges: (i) he did not clearly distinguish between combination and division, and (ii) he reduced combination and division to a single fallacy. My explanation of the fallacies uses the notion of scope of an expression: in modern terminology, the fallacy of combination can be described as ?fallacy of the wide scope?, the fallacy of division as ?fallacy of the narrow scope?
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
The Complete Works of Aristotle. The Revised Oxford Translation.Jonathan Barnes - 1986 - Revue Philosophique de la France Et de l'Etranger 176 (4):493-494.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Rethinking the Fallacy of Hasty Generalization.Douglas Walton - 1999 - Argumentation 13 (2):161-182.
Aristotle: Topica and Sophistici Elenchi W. D. Ross: Aristotelis Topica Et Sophistici Elenchi. (Script. Class. Bibl. Oxon.) Pp. Viii+260. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1958. Cloth, 25s. Net. [REVIEW]Hugh Tredennick - 1961 - The Classical Review 11 (01):33-34.
“How Can a Philosophical Enquiry Be Conducted Without a Perpetual Petitio Principii?Frank Ramsey - unknown
Commentators and Commentaries on Aristotle's Sophistici Elenchi: A Study of Post-Aristotelian Ancient and Medieval Writings on Fallacies.Sten Ebbesen - 1981 - E.J. Brill.
Aristotle on Fallacies, or, the Sophistici Elenchi. Aristotle - 1866 - Garland.
Added to index2010-08-10
Total downloads27 ( #191,396 of 2,177,988 )
Recent downloads (6 months)2 ( #166,811 of 2,177,988 )
How can I increase my downloads?