Disagreement, Error and Two Senses of Incompatibility—The Relational Function of Discursive Updating
David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Philosophia 40 (1):121-138 (2012)
In Between Saying and Doing: Towards an Analytic Pragmatism , Robert B. Brandom puts forward a general method of formally representing relations between meaning and use (between vocabularies and practices-or-abilities) and shows how discursive intentionality can be understood as a pragmatically mediated semantic relation. In this context, the activity that pragmatically mediates the semantic relations characteristic of discursive intentionality is specified as a practice of discursive updating —a practice of rectifying commitments and removing incompatibilities. The aim of the paper is to take a closer look at the practice of discursive updating and to show that the role of inconsistencies and disagreements in discursive practice can only be fully understood if the interactional dimension of updating processes is taken into account—i.e. if one looks at the explicitly social, interactional role of discursive updating in cases of disagreements between different subjects
|Keywords||Social interaction Disagreement Incompatibility|
No categories specified
(categorize this paper)
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
Robert Brandom (2000). Articulating Reasons: An Introduction to Inferentialism. Harvard University Press.
Robert Brandom (2008). Between Saying and Doing: Towards an Analytic Pragmatism. Oxford University Press.
Robert Brandom (1979). Freedom and Constraint by Norms. American Philosophical Quarterly 16 (3):187 - 196.
Robert Brandom (2000). Facts, Norms, and Normative Facts: A Reply to Habermas. European Journal of Philosophy 8 (3):356–374.
Robert Brandom (ed.) (2000). Rorty and His Critics. Blackwell Publishers.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
David Lauer (2012). Expressivism and the Layer Cake Picture of Discursive Practice. Philosophia 40 (1):55-73.
Kenneth Shockley (2006). On Participation and Membership in Discursive Practices. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 36 (1):67-85.
Mark Lance (2001). The Logical Structure of Linguistic Commitment III Brandomian Scorekeeping and Incompatibility. Journal of Philosophical Logic 30 (5):439-464.
Carlo Martini (2013). A Puzzle About Belief Updating. Synthese 190 (15):3149-3160.
T. Midtgarden (2013). Conflicting and Complementary Conceptions of Discursive Practice in Non-Metaphysical Interpretations of Hegel. Philosophy and Social Criticism 39 (6):559-576.
Eva Bendix Petersen (2008). The Conduct of Concern: Exclusionary Discursive Practices and Subject Positions in Academia. Educational Philosophy and Theory 40 (3):394–406.
Daniele Porello (2012). Incompatibility Semantics From Agreement. Philosophia 40 (1):99-119.
Paul G. La Forge (1997). Teaching Business Ethics Through Meditation. Journal of Business Ethics 16 (12/13):1283 - 1295.
Gustav Jahoda (2013). Critical Comments on Experimental, Discursive, and General Social Psychology. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 43 (3):341-360.
James Hawthorne (2004). Three Models of Sequential Belief Updating on Uncertain Evidence. Journal of Philosophical Logic 33 (1):89-123.
Jordan Howard Sobel (2009). Modus Ponens and Modus Tollens for Conditional Probabilities, and Updating on Uncertain Evidence. Theory and Decision 66 (2):103 - 148.
Anatolij Karas (2008). “Ukrainian Project” and It's Discursive-Ethical Obstacles. Proceedings of the Xxii World Congress of Philosophy 50:309-315.
Piet Strydom (2006). Intersubjectivity – Interactionist or Discursive? Reflections on Habermas’ Critique of Brandom. Philosophy and Social Criticism 32 (2):155-172.
Paul G. La Forge (1997). Teaching Business Ethics Through Meditation. Journal of Business Ethics 16 (12-13):1283-1295.
Roopen N. Majithia (2006). Function, Intuition and Ends in Aristotle's Ethics. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 9 (2):187 - 200.
Added to index2011-03-28
Total downloads17 ( #97,706 of 1,101,579 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #292,059 of 1,101,579 )
How can I increase my downloads?