Ancient Philosophy

ISSNs: 0740-2007, 2154-4689

19 found

View year:

  1.  32
    Review of André Laks, Plato’s Second Republic: An Essay on the Laws (Princeton University Press, 2022). [REVIEW]John M. Armstrong - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):279-282.
    André Laks aims to clarify how Plato’s Laws ‘pursues a philosophical project consisting in a rationalization of law, in as much as that is possible’ (4). According to Laks, Plato implicitly distinguishes law’s content from its discursive form. Law’s content is ‘a deontic proposition ultimately dictated by “reason”/nous’; its discursive form is ‘an order or command usually followed by the threat of punishments’ (4). On Laks’s interpretation, commands are violent and irrational, so ideal legislative discourse omits them. I question this. (...)
    Direct download (3 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  2.  37
    ‘In a Complete Life’ (NE i 7.1098a18): Aristotle on Happiness, Time and Immortality.Samuel Baker - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):193-220.
    Aristotle’s fundamental rationale for the ‘teleios life’ requirement (Nicomachean Ethics i 7.1098a18) is that a virtuous activity is better when it is more continuous and more enduring. Consequently, the Aristotelian wish (boulēsis) for happiness properly inclines the virtuous person to wish for immortality. This is not an incoherent wish because mortality is coincidental to the human being as such.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  3.  13
    The Realm of Mimesis in Plato: Orality, Writing, and the Ontology of the Image, by Mariangela Esposito.Ryan M. Brown - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):286-292.
  4.  10
    Hypotheses and Mathematical Intermediates in the Republic.Miriam Byrd - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):83-105.
    Though Socrates appears to present examples of mathematicians hypothesizing entities in Republic 510c3-6, most interpreters assume that he really means that they hypothesize propositions. After establishing the plausibility of the entities interpretation, I show that it is fruitful in respect to locating the objects of dianoia, addressing the question of whether Plato held a theory of mathematical intermediates, and explaining the inferiority of mathematical reasoning to dialectic.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  5. Aristotle on the Individuation of Syllogisms.Phil Corkum - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):171-191.
    Discussion of the Aristotelian syllogistic over the last sixty years has arguably centered on the question whether syllogisms are inferences or implications. But the significance of this debate at times has been taken to concern whether the syllogistic is a logic or a theory, and how it ought to be represented by modern systems. Largely missing from this discussion has been a study of the few passages in the Prior Analytics where Aristotle provides explicit guidance on how to individuate syllogisms. (...)
    Direct download (3 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark   1 citation  
  6.  13
    Cratylus’ Silence About Linguistic Correctness.Sean Driscoll - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):107-128.
    This article addresses the longstanding puzzle of what Cratylus’ silence means. It argues that Plato’s Cratylus goes silent to convey his position regarding the correctness of names, and it does this by demonstrating how Cratylus is silent in imitation of a literary trope for portraying the significance of a character’s silence. The philosophical payoff of this imitation is that, for Cratylus, correctness consists not in saying, but in showing.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  7.  31
    Fractured Goodness: Aristotle’s Response to Plato’s Form of the Good, by Christopher Shields.Lloyd P. Gerson - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):292-299.
  8.  19
    Forms as Objects of Thought in Aristotle’s On Ideas.Edgar Gonzalez-Varela - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):151-169.
    The argument from thinking in Aristotle’s On Ideas deals with the problem of ‘presence in absence’. It argues that, to solve it, one must posit Forms. Scholars claim that Aristotle takes the argument as valid either for Forms or for his own universals. I argue against both alternatives, for Aristotle thinks that the problem that motivates the argument does not require a metaphysical solution, but only a psychological solution.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  9.  17
    Cynic Egalitarianism, Cynic Misogyny?Emily Hulme - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):39-52.
    The Cynics were radically anti-conventional Greek philosophers who held egalitarian views about gender. They are also associated with extremely misogynistic anecdotes. How can one square this tension? I argue we must look to their ethical naturalism, on the basis of which they opposed convention, culture, and all that smacks of superficiality. This, combined with a longstanding stereotype about ‘feminine artifice’, explains (but does not justify) Cynic hostility toward the feminine.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  10.  6
    From Death to Life: Key Themes in Plato’s Phaedo, by Franco Trabattoni.Orestis Karatzoglou - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):282-286.
  11.  25
    Thales’s Conception of the Earth.Radim Kocandrle - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):1-19.
    Aristotle ascribes to Thales of Miletus the notion of the Earth resting on water. However, in archaic Ionian cosmologies the Earth was not viewed as a cosmic body resting on physical support. The very motif is likely to have originated in the Near East. If Aristotle claims that this was the oldest conception of stability of the Earth it is possible that Thales may have been associated with it anachronistically.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  12.  13
    Defining Rhetoric Dialectically.Jens Kristian Larsen - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):53-81.
    This article urges that what distinguishes dialectic from rhetoric in the Gorgias is their differing conceptions of definitions and argues that: (1) Dialectic centers on the nature of things, rhetoric on their qualities. (2) Dialectic is shown to differ from rhetoric in the inquiry through the application of collection and division. (3) Socrates’ definition and criticism of rhetoric flows from his conception of expertise, not his moral outlook.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  13.  19
    Dialectic’s Role in Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics x 7.David Merry - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):237-257.
    According to a once standard view, the NE is dialectical in the sense that its starting points are endoxa and that it follows a ‘dialectical procedure’ of setting out the endoxa, finding problems among the endoxa, and resolving these problems. In more recent years, however, scholars have pushed back against this view, arguing that Aristotle’s investigations in the NE are guided by scientific norms outlined in the Analytics. Supporters of this ‘scientific’ interpretation leave little room for dialectic. Although I agree (...)
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  14.  6
    Porphyry, Elitism, and Origen.Ilaria L. E. Ramelli - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):259-278.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  15.  13
    The Continuum of Logos and Unity of Plato’s Phaedrus.Colin C. Smith - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):129-150.
    At Phaedrus 264c2-5, Socrates asserts that good logos is a well-measured unity containing extremes (ἄκρα) and intermediates (μέσα). This raises questions of whether and how Phaedrus is unified. I argue that it is, and describe its unity through principles from Philebus concerning extremes and intermediates. Phaedrus, I argue, exhibits a discursive-method range as a logos continuum bounded by the self-serving (ἴδιος) discourse of the idiot (ἰδιώτης) and the commonness (κοινός) of dialectic.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  16. Curable and Incurable Vice in Aristotle.Eric Solis - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):221-236.
    I argue that central to Aristotle’s account of vice is a distinction between two varieties of vicious person: those for whom character change is possible (the curable), and those for whom it is not (the incurable). Recognizing this distinction and drawing out the ideas which ground it shows why Aristotle’s discussions of vice in EN vii and ix 4 are not inconsistent.
    Direct download (3 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  17.  11
    The Invention of Imagination, by Justin Humphreys.Rosemary Twomey - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):300-303.
  18.  13
    What Kind of Not-Being Is Democritus’ Void?Vasia Vergouli - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):21-38.
    The paper focuses on Democritus’ void (κενόν) as not-being and tackles two interrelated puzzles: (a) whether the two starting-points of the atomic theory, atoms and void, should be considered as equivalent and (b) how nothing can be something. It offers a close examination of the passages concerning emptiness in tandem with the corresponding views of Parmenides and Melissus, and then it reassesses Aristotle’s idea of a link between the notions of void and place.
    Direct download (2 more)  
     
    Export citation  
     
    Bookmark  
  19.  13
    Aristotle’s Parva Naturalia: Text, Translation, and Commentary, by Ronald Polansky.Justin Winzenrieth - 2025 - Ancient Philosophy 45 (1):303-308.
 Previous issues
  
Next issues